The Book Tower
debut novel coming soon

RSS feed

Saturday Night Monsters

Monday March 19, 2007 in television | science fiction

The Saturday night TV series Primeval has been billed as ITV’s answer to Doctor Who. It’s taken them long enough to think of something – or has it? Charlie Brooker, in his entertaining Screenwipes on BBC4, sees Sapphire and Steel as ITV’s original rival to Doctor Who. There’s also The Tomorrow People, which ran for a few years in the 70s, and let’s not forget Space 1999, Gerry Anderson’s short lived effort also from the same period. But let’s face it, ITV’s competition to Doctor Who has always been a bit thin on the ground.

So how does Primeval fare? Pretty good, at least in my house. It’s better than Torchwood, and after watching the final episode on Saturday I’m going to suggest that it might be better than Doctor Who. Primeval is about Professor Nick Cutter, played by Douglas Henshall, and his small team of young and attractive people who are investigating an outbreak of anomalies. This is a word that crops up quite frequently in the series, and an anomaly in this context is a hole in time (or something like that) which gives the excuse for Primeval‘s main premise – all sorts of dangerous prehistoric monsters sneaking through the anomalies and rampaging around in modern settings.

Scenarios so far have included:

  • A dinosaur rampaging through some woods and deliberately terrorising a small boy
  • Huge scorpions loose on the London Underground
  • A prehistoric crocodile at large
  • Dodos. Okay – not very frightening – but these ones carry a rather nasty parasite
  • A homage to Hitchcock’s The Birds with the skies full of prehistoric winged creatures
  • Just as we’re becoming over familiar with prehistoric monsters, a dangerous predator from the future

Primeval also has a subplot involving Cutter’s wife Helen, missing and presumed dead until she is discovered living in and out of the anomalies. She knows a lot about what’s going on, much more than she’s prepared to let on. She’s also one of the most headstrong female characters I’ve ever seen in a British TV series, somebody for who the term doesn’t suffer fools glady is most apt. She won’t take any shit, and when it’s Helen materialising from an anomaly instead of a 20 foot dinosaur I’m more afraid.

Character-wise, there’s a lot for the viewer to get their teeth into, with several interlocking love triangles being revealed as the series progressed. Apparently Hannah Spearitt has caused quite a stir by skipping around in her panties, and if you search for Primeval on YouTube these are the scenes that you are most likely to find. All of the actors make a good job of making the preposterous premise believable, and Ben Miller provides a comic turn as a disbelieving top civil servant.

The series manages to pull off all of the ridiculous situations it throws at us, there’s some outstanding special effects (are we supposed to say “CGI” these days?), and – unlike Torchwood – all of the supporting team are quite likeable. Primeval also had one of the best cliffhanger endings for its final episode that I’ve ever seen, throwing the gauntlet down at Doctor Who‘s feet and shouting “touché!”

Better than Torchwood? Better than Torchwood? Pah! Give me Captain Jack Harkness any day…

JackP    Tuesday March 20, 2007   

Blimey. I expected to pee off a few Who fans. But Torchwood fans? Blimey.

The Book Tower    Tuesday March 20, 2007   

Just think about it….

Torchwood = Captain Jack = brilliant programme.
Star Trek The Next Generation = Captain Picard = brilliant programme.

It’s no coincidence :-)

And the problem with Dr Who ( whispers quietly so as not to get mugged by the Whoers ) is that it’s more faaaamily ain’t it? Not enough blood and thunder, guts and garters. For starters.

Oh, it’s still brilliant, don’t get me wrong – I’m eagerly anticipating the next series – but I’m looking forward to the next series of Torchwood more...

JackP    Tuesday March 20, 2007   

My problem with Doctor Who and with Torchwood is that they are wildly inconsistent. I’ll end up watching a brilliant episode of Doctor Who on my own – like the one when he goes back to the French revolution – and then say to my wife “you must watch this!” So we sit down to watch the next one but it’s the silly episode with Peter Kay as an alien.
Torchwood is even more unpredictable – there’s some brilliant episodes like the one with the cannibals in the Welsh village but also some very daft ones like the one where the boy tries to sell an alien eye on eBay.
I’ll keep watching though, and I agree that John Barrowman is a real star.

And I like Primeval because it's family and I feel less nerdy not watching science fiction on my own (and for some reason my daughter doesn't mind dinosaurs - she loves Jurassic Park, but she won't watch Doctor Who because she has an aversion to aliens).

The Book Tower    Tuesday March 20, 2007   

your_ip_is_blacklisted_by sbl.spamhaus.org